The blog has been so successful that I'm hesitant to suggest a change. I think that the
"just for fun" nature of it is important to that success. However, I think there's no reason why we couldn't be helping each other improve while we're at it.
So here's what I propose: If you want help, ask for suggestions when you post your image. If you don't want help, don't ask for suggestions.
People can either leave critiques in your comments or e-mail them to you, according to your request. These critiques could also include posting or e-mailing paintovers, if the person asks for them.
If you're entering an image just for fun and don't want critiques on it, we'll respect that and just give "good job!" comments instead. Once again, I think the fun of the mini-challenge is probably the most important part.
But I'd love to see the art-smarts getting passed around a little more, too.
Any thoughts?
Also, I had the idea that some of the topics could include an optional design exercise like:
Topic: Castle Ghoulsmire. Optional Exercise: Repetition of shape---try to unify the design by creatively using similar shapes throughout your imageThis would be additional criteria for those who are really trying to push themselves to improve, but completely optional for use when drawing for the topic. Does anyone like that idea as well?